Old Testament New Testament Bible Scripture
 

After His resurrection, why did Jesus tell Mary not to touch Him, but later tell Thomas to touch Him?



Question: "After His resurrection, why did Jesus tell Mary not to touch Him, but later tell Thomas to touch Him?"

Answer:
Jesus tells Mary, ?Touch Me not? (John 20:17, KJV); but then later, speaking to Thomas, He says, ?Reach hither thy finger and behold My hands; and reach hither thy hand, and thrust it into My side? (verse 27). The seeming incongruity of Jesus? statements is resolved when we examine the language Jesus employed and consider the basic difference between the two situations.

In John 20:17, the word translated ?touch? is a Greek word which means ?to cling to, to lay hold of.? This wasn?t just a touch; it was a grip. Obviously, when Mary recognized Jesus, she immediately clung to Him. Matthew 28:9 records the other women doing the same thing when they saw the resurrected Christ.

Mary?s reaction was motivated, possibly, by several things. One is simply her loving devotion to the Lord. Mary is overwhelmed by the events of the morning, and as her grief turns to joy, she naturally embraces Jesus. Another motivation is Mary?s desire to restore the fellowship that death had broken. She had lost Him once, and she was going to make sure she didn?t lose Him again?she wanted to keep Jesus with her always. Also, Mary may have been thinking that this was the fulfillment of Jesus? promise to return (John 14:3), in which case He would take her (and all believers) with Him to heaven.

However, it was not Jesus? plan to stay in this world always, and His resurrection was not to be seen as His promised return. That is why He tells Mary of the ascension. His plan was to ascend to the Father and then send the Holy Spirit (John 16:7; 20:22; Acts 2:1-4). Fellowship with Jesus would continue, but it would be a spiritual communion, not a physical presence.

In loosening Mary?s hold on Him, Jesus was, in effect, saying this: ?I know you desire to keep Me here, always present with you. I know you want everything to be just the same as before I died. But our relationship is about to change. I?m going to heaven, and you will have the Comforter in My place. You need to start walking by faith, Mary, not by sight.?

When Jesus spoke to Thomas, it was not to counter a misplaced desire but to rebuke a lack of faith. Thomas had said he would not believe until he had touched the living body of Jesus (John 20:25). Jesus, knowing all about Thomas?s declaration, offered His body as living proof of His resurrection. This was something He did on another occasion as well (Luke 24:39-40).

So, both Mary and Thomas needed more faith. Mary needed faith enough to let Jesus go. Thomas needed faith enough to believe without empirical proof. Mary needed to loosen her grip; Thomas needed to strengthen his. The resurrected Christ gave both of them the faith they needed.


Related Topics:

Is the resurrection of Jesus Christ true?

Where was Jesus for the three days between His death and resurrection?

Why should I believe in Christ?s resurrection?

What does it mean to be a born again Christian?

Who is Jesus Christ?



Return to:

Questions about Jesus Christ


Return to:

elhijodedios.com Home


After His resurrection, why did Jesus tell Mary not to touch Him, but later tell Thomas to touch Him?

 

Questions About God

Does God exist?

Who is God?

Is God real?

Is God dead?

What are the attributes of God? What is God like?

What does the Bible teach about the Trinity?

Can monotheism be proven?

What is Theology Proper / Paterology?

Why does God allow bad things to happen to good people?

Did God create evil?

Why does God allow the innocent to suffer?

Does God love everyone or just Christians?

Is God sovereign, or do we have a free will?

What are the different names of God, and what do they mean?

Where was God on September 11th?

Why doesn't God still perform miracles like He did in the Bible?

Does God hear / answer the prayers of a sinner / unbeliever?

Why does God love us?

Why was God so evident in the Bible and seems so hidden today?

Does God punish us when we sin?

Why is God a jealous God?

Who created God? Where did God come from?

How do I get the image of God as imposing and angry out of my mind?

Does God change His mind?

Has anyone ever seen God?

What does it mean to fear God?

Is it wrong to question God?

Is there anything God can't do?

Does God have a sense of humor?

Why is God so different in the Old Testament than He is in the New Testament?

Is God / the Bible sexist?

Why does God demand, seek, or request that we worship Him?

Is God fair?

Why did God command the extermination of the Canaanites?

Is God male or female?

What is YHWH? What is the tetragrammaton?

Does God make mistakes?

What does God look like?

Why does God allow sickness?

What does it mean that God is love?

Why does God create people when He knows they are going to go to hell?

Why does God allow evil men like Hitler and Saddam to come into power?

Does God tempt us to sin? What about Abraham in Genesis chapter 22?

What is deism? What do deists believe?

Does God still speak to us today?

Why does God allow natural disasters, i.e. earthquakes, hurricanes, and tsunamis?

What was God doing before He created the universe?

What is God's will?

What is the immutability of God?

Could God create a rock so heavy He could not lift it?

Why does God refer to Himself in the plural in Genesis 1:26 and 3:22?

Why does God require faith?

Does God help those who help themselves?

Why does God allow birth defects?

Why does Scripture emphasize the right hand of God?

Does God have a physical body?

Can God sin? If God cannot sin, is He truly omnipotent?

What does it mean that God is infinite?

Why does God allow evil?

Why does Isaiah 45:7 say that God created evil?

Where is God now? Where is God when it hurts?

Does God want us to worship Him as Father?

Is it sometimes God's will for believers to be sick?

What is the key to truly knowing God?

How is belief in God any different from belief in a Flying Spaghetti Monster?

Why won't God heal amputees?

Is God cruel?

Is God imaginary?

Why did God allow the Holocaust?

What does it mean to find God?