Is it acceptable to "lay out a fleece" before God in prayer?
Question: "Is it acceptable to "lay out a fleece" before God in prayer?"
Answer: The concept of “putting out a fleece” comes from the story of Gideon, a leader in Israel, in Judges 6. When God directed him to gather the Israelite troops to defeat the Midianite invaders, Gideon wanted to be sure it was really God’s voice he was hearing and that he was understanding His directions. He asked God for a sign to prove that this was truly His will. So he put out a piece of wool overnight and asked God to make it wet while keeping the surrounding dirt dry. God graciously did as Gideon asked and in the morning the fleece was wet enough to produce a bowl of water when it was wrung out.
But Gideon’s faith was so weak that he asked God for another sign—this time to keep another fleece dry while making the surrounding dirt wet. Again, God complied and Gideon was finally convinced that God meant what He said and that the nation of Israel would have the victory the angel of the Lord had promised in Judges 6:14-16. Putting out the fleeces was the second time Gideon asked for a sign that God was really talking to him and would do what He said he would.
There are several lessons for us in Gideon’s story. First, God is incredibly gracious and patient with us, especially when our faith is weak and causes us much confusion. Gideon knew he was treading on dangerous ground and was trying God’s patience by asking for multiple signs. After the first fleece sign, he said, “Do not be angry with me. Let me make one more request” (Judges 6:39). But our God is a merciful, loving and patient God who knows our weaknesses. However, the story of Gideon should be for our instruction and not serve as a model for our own behavior. Jesus said on two occasions that “a wicked and adulterous generation seeks after a sign” (Matthew 12:39; 16:1-4). His point was that the signs He had already given them—His fulfillment of Old Testament prophecy, healings, miracles—were sufficient signs for them to respond to the truth, if truth was what they were seeking. Clearly it was not.
Another lesson of Gideon’s fleeces is that those asking for signs are exhibiting a weak and immature faith that won’t be convinced by the signs anyway! Gideon had received more than enough information without the sign of the fleeces. God had told him he would have victory (v. 14) and He had responded to a previous request for a sign with a miraculous display of power in fire (v. 16). But still Gideon asked for two more signs because of his own insecurity. In the same way, when we ask for a sign from God, even when He does provide it, it doesn’t give us the answer we crave because our unsure, wavering faith doubts that it was from God. That often leads us to ask for multiple signs, none of which give us the assurance we need, because the problem isn’t with God’s power, it’s with our own perception of it.
A problem with following Gideon’s example of fleece-setting is that it does not take into account that our situation and his are really not comparable. As Christians, we have two powerful tools that Gideon lacked. First, we have the complete Word of God which we know is “God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16-17). God has assured us that His Word is all we need to be “thoroughly equipped” for anything and everything life throws at us. We do not need experiential proof (signs, voices, miracles) to verify what He has already told us in His Word. But what about those decisions that are not specifically addressed in the Bible? This is where our second advantage over Gideon comes into play. Every Christian has the Holy Spirit, who is God Himself, residing in our hearts to guide, direct, and encourage us. Prior to Pentecost, believers had the Old Testament only and were directed externally by God’s providential hand. Now we have His complete Bible and His indwelling presence in our hearts.
Here’s an example of how these two factors work together to guide us in decision-making. Suppose a young Christian woman wants to marry a young man. So far, so good—marriage is honorable and pleasing to God. However, although he claims to be a Christian, the young man shows no real interest in the things of the Lord, he has a problem with not always telling the truth (although his excuses are numerous and ever-present), and her parents have doubts about his confession of faith. The young woman knows what the Bible teaches about Christian character and she also feels the gentle nudge of the Spirit informing her conscience that the young man will not make a good husband in God’s eyes. Yet, she loves him. So she decides to ask God for a “sign” whether or not to marry him. Because God has graciously given us His Word and His Spirit, should He give her a personal sign to verify what both have already told her? And would she believe the sign anyway? Or would she more likely ask for another sign and keep asking until she gets the answer she wants?
Rather than seeking signs via fleeces, we should be content to know God’s will for us in every situation every day: “Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly” (Colossians 3:16), “Be joyful always; pray continually; give thanks in all circumstances, for this is God's will for you in Christ Jesus” (1 Thessalonians 5:16-18), “And whatever you do, whether in word or deed, do it all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him” (Colossians 3:17). If these things characterize our lives, the decisions we make will be in accordance with God’s will, He will bless us immeasurably with His peace and assurance, and putting out fleeces or asking for signs will never even enter our minds.
Recommended Resource: Prayer, The Great Adventure by David Jeremiah.
What are some hindrances to effective prayer?
What is the power of prayer?
What is the prayer of Jabez?
What is the proper way to pray?
Is it allowable to use candles in connection with prayer?
Questions about Prayer
Is it acceptable to "lay out a fleece" before God in prayer?